Home › Guides › Renovation, GC & carpentry › How to choose flooring: compare hardwood, laminate, vinyl and tile
GuideNew flooring transforms a home and is one of the most impactful renovations — but with so many options, choosing the right one for each room is where people get stuck. The best floor depends on the room, your lifestyle, moisture, budget and how long you want it to last. Here's how to compare the options and choose well.
The biggest mistake is putting the wrong floor in the wrong room. Moisture-prone areas (bathrooms, kitchens, basements, laundry) need water-resistant options like tile or luxury vinyl, not solid hardwood or laminate. High-traffic areas need durability. Bedrooms can prioritize comfort. Start with the room's demands, then choose the material that fits.
Solid hardwood is beautiful, long-lasting and can be refinished multiple times, but it's sensitive to moisture and costs more. Engineered wood has a real-wood top layer over a stable core, handles humidity better, and suits more rooms (though it can be refinished fewer times). Both add warmth and strong resale appeal — but keep them out of wet areas.
Laminate is affordable and durable with a photographic wood or stone look, but traditional laminate doesn't love water. Luxury vinyl (plank or tile) has surged in popularity because it's highly water-resistant, durable, comfortable underfoot, realistic-looking and budget-friendly — making it a favourite for busy households, kitchens and basements. For many homes it's the practical sweet spot.
Tile (ceramic or porcelain) is the most water- and wear-resistant option — ideal for bathrooms, kitchens and entryways — though it's hard and cold underfoot. Carpet brings warmth, softness and sound dampening to bedrooms and basements, but holds allergens and wears in high traffic. Each has its place; the room decides.
Cheaper floors can cost more over time if they wear out or fail in the wrong room. Weigh the upfront price against lifespan, maintenance and whether it suits the space. Factor in installation (some floors are far more labour-intensive), subfloor prep, and removal of the old floor — these affect the real total, so get itemized quotes.
Even great flooring fails if it's installed poorly — subfloor prep, acclimation, moisture barriers, expansion gaps and proper technique all determine how it looks and lasts. Some floors are DIY-friendly; tile and hardwood reward a pro. On Genie, flooring supply and installation go to vetted, insured pros at a quoted price, with the work captured and protected until it's done.
Every task in this guide is something you can book on Genie — vetted, insured pros at an upfront or quoted price:
Water-resistant options — tile or luxury vinyl — not solid hardwood or traditional laminate, which don't handle moisture. Tile is the most water- and wear-resistant; luxury vinyl is durable, water-resistant and comfortable underfoot.
Laminate is affordable with a photographic look but doesn't love water; luxury vinyl is highly water-resistant, durable, realistic and comfortable — making it a favourite for kitchens, basements and busy households.
Some floors (like click-together vinyl) are DIY-friendly, but tile and hardwood reward a pro — subfloor prep, moisture barriers and technique determine how it looks and lasts. Genie offers flooring supply and install from vetted pros.
